Смекни!
smekni.com

Robert Bly On Male Violence Essay Research (стр. 2 из 2)

and we need to keep that. I said, “It’s easier to socialize a young man into being a

warrior than to be a father.” You can do that in the marine corp. And men are geared

for that in some way, but to socialize them into being fathers is a different matter. We

should be honoring fathers instead of attacking them. I think all of the older men have to

be one of the reasons we like young men to come. This weekend if we say if you want to

bring your son, he comes free. Because it’s important for the son to hear the fathers say

how important fathering has been to them. How important it is in their life. How it’s

twice as important as anything they thought they were doing in business. Young men need to

learn that. So I say it’s as hard to socialize a young man into being a decent and

responsible father as to socialize them into being a decent and responsible artist. In the

sibling society you’re supposed to have no training and become an artist in fifteen

minutes, be a father in fifteen minutes. No, so we have to decide, do we want to allow the

military to keep deciding what masculinity is. Or would we like to take some part in it

ourselves? And I understand the amount of anger that women feel over the patriarchies

demeaning of women, my wife and my mother feel tremendous anger about that. And yet all

men are lumped together and we say all men are rapists or all men are patriarchal, that’s

not socializing men to be responsible fathers. It’s shaming them again.

Q: Why are women and the feminine so feared by men?

Well, I’ve already mentioned, I’ll just mention it again. They are afraid of being

shamed. Why are men afraid of women? The answer that’s being given now is a very strange

one. That all fetuses in the womb are originally female, we know that. And when the baby’s

marked to be a boy at about the age of six weeks, changes begin to occur, two hundred

fifty of them. This eventually changes the body from a female into male, changes the

brain, changes all these things. So, when the boy comes out he’s really not sure that he’s

a man. Men are an experimental species. And the boy’s afraid he’s going to slide back.

This takes place below the level of consciousness. But you can still feel it in

seventeen-year-old boys. That’s why they go to military school. Because there will be no

one around there that will be feminine male. And they see a feminine male, they feel

terrified that somehow they will slip back again. That’s the terror.

Male terror of homosexuality. They’re afraid they are going to slip back again into the

place in which they came. Now that was the purpose of initiation in the old days. That

when the boy comes out of the womb his body is masculine but he isn’t finished. The

journey isn’t finished at all, and the older men then would come in at the age of 8 or 10

or 12 and say, we’ll finish this journey. We are going to try to teach you what adult

masculinity really is like. And in places what they would do is take the boy away from the

mother, bring him out in the woods and then the old men would dance for a night and a

day-and-a-half, tell incredible stories and the boy’s eyes get big — is this what being

male is. And that is very beautiful. And then they’d tell him stories and all of that.

Women should not oppose the initiation processes of the boy, because the attempt is not

to brutalize the boy, but to lead him forward into a kind of responsible and gentle

masculinity that he’ll never pick up out of television. So there are many initiatory

practices that are cruel and brutal, but that doesn’t mean that you throw away the

possibility of initiation.

The thing that I have said that’s had the most effect is that both men and women need

mentors. They need older women and older men as mentors. And the other day I was at a

funeral in a New Hampshire and a woman came up to me and said she wanted to thank me

because she had three sons and her father and husband died and she read my book and

understood about the male mentor. And she said she wanted to show me a picture of her

youngest son. She wanted me to know he’s got a mentor now in school, a coach, and the

coach is very sweet to him and to see how the boy looks when he has a mentor. You

understand what I’m saying? And women have to understand that about their sons. And you

have to be careful in picking a mentor. There are a lot of wicked old men out there. Can’t

be sentimental about that. You have to check them out. But there are certain things that

only a male mentor can do that the mother, no matter how great she is, won’t be able to

do. And I think it’s true of women too. That no matter if the father is raising the

daughter alone, no matter how good he is, they would still need an older women as a mentor

for her. In Minneapolis there is a wonderful old woman, MaryDella Sir, who’s an old

commie. She’s about 88 years old now and they have women’s meetings in Minneapolis so the

young women can come and just look at her.

Q: You’ve said that masculinity is denied in our culture. Some feminists have

responded to your work saying that a men’s movement encourages rigid gender roles and

creates a sort of masculinist nationalism that further consolidates male power. What’s

your response?

The purpose of having men’s groups to which you invite younger men is that the younger

men need teachers as to how to go into a gentle and responsible masculinity. And the

mothers try to teach them, but the fathers and the older men need to also. They’re never

going to learn gentle responsible masculinity from the mass media or the television. So we

have to say that.

Q: If the mass media and popular culture condone or encourage violence, how can

we curb violence when good parenting isn’t present to counteract those pervasive forces?

You’ve talked a lot about the importance of mentoring. Isn’t that a solution?

As for decreasing violence. If you have an unparented child, something will happen.

When you’re looking at gangs of young men, you’re looking at young men who have no older

man in their life at all. And when a young man feels unparented, he will try to burn your

city down for you. When a young woman feels unparented, she may become depressed or have a

teenage baby, but a boy will become violent. And we have to realize that the greatest

danger to the culture is coming from these young unparented males all over the world. And

if we want to do something about that, instead of pouring money in from Washington, one

thing you would do is you would go to South Los Angeles and you would ask in the black

communities who is a responsible older male here. And they would know. They only know that

at the block level. Then you’d go to that older man and you’d say to him, “Listen,

I’m gonna give you eighteen thousand dollars and I want you to keep two young men out of

prison in that time.. It costs thirty-five thousand to keep a young man in prison. It

costs more to keep a young man in prison than to send him to college.” And the older

man then has something to do and the younger man has someone to talk to and be with. And

it’s astonishing the changes that come in young men when that happens. We do a lot of work

in this group now with gangs. Sometimes we have fifty-percent black men and sometimes

thirty-five percent of those are gang members. There was one in Los Angeles in which two

young men came in who’d already killed over eight men and were there. And it’s astonishing

how they will change when they realize there’s older men who are interested in them.

Online Source: http://www.pbs.org/kued/nosafeplace/interv/bly.html